Pan, Techo y Fuego

Guide

Toothache Before Anesthesia: Madrid, 1799

Grades 7–8 (US) · early modern Europe: the city and daily life

History · 15 min

Pressing play loads YouTube (Google). Privacy

What it is for

Understand how people endured toothache in Madrid in 1799, without anesthesia, from newspaper advertisements and books of the time, and tell apart what those sources say, what the episode imagines for a family and what nobody knows.

Key moments

  1. ▶ 0:44

    A worm, or a hole

    To open the lesson: many people believed a tiny worm gnawed the tooth; the daughter looks and finds no worm, only a hole. About 50 seconds.

  2. ▶ 1:33

    Cloves, plasters and a poultice

    The core: the remedies the books of the time proposed (cloves, plasters, mastic, poultice), told as history and not as advice. A little over 2 minutes.

  3. ▶ 10:14

    The bloodletter: down on the floor

    To see how a tooth was pulled according to the bloodletters' manual, without detail: the posture and the care afterwards. About 2 and a half minutes.

  4. ▶ 12:46

    No anesthesia, and no known price

    To debate: no anesthesia and no known price; what is known, what is not and why the episode says so. One minute.

Images to project

The episode's images, large: tap one to open it full screen. The illustrations are a reconstruction; the documents are sources of the period.

Questions

  1. What did many people believe caused toothache, and what does the daughter find in the grandfather's mouth? (from 0:44)
  2. Before going to the bloodletter, which home remedies were tried according to the books of the time? Does the episode recommend them? (from 1:33)
  3. In Madrid in 1799, who could pull a tooth? How did the dentist and the sacamuelas (tooth-puller) differ? (from 7:02)
  4. According to the bloodletters' manual, where was the patient seated to have a tooth pulled, and what was done afterwards? (from 10:14)
  5. How much did it cost to have a tooth pulled in Madrid in 1799, and what does the episode do when the sources do not say? (from 12:46)
Answers for the teacher · Open them to see and print them.
  1. Many people believed there was a tiny worm inside the tooth, gnawing at it and causing the pain. It was a belief, and the episode does not present it as true: in the imagined scene, the daughter looks into the grandfather's mouth and finds no worm, only a hole, a decayed tooth. It is best not to date the belief to Madrid in 1799: the sources say «many people believed», with no place or year.
  2. Cotton or lint (flax threads) soaked in clove essence was put into the decayed tooth: it was the most repeated remedy in the books of the time. Plasters were placed on the temples and behind the ears. Mastic, a resin, was used, and the bloodletters' manual also proposed rinses of water and vinegar boiled with alum. On the swollen cheek, other books put a poultice of bread crumb and milk. These are remedies of their time, told as history: the episode does not say they worked and warns that none of them is recommended today.
  3. There were dentists who advertised in the newspaper as approved by the Real Protomedicato, the tribunal that granted licences, and there were sacamuelas: according to a dictionary of 1786, the dentist treated or preserved teeth and the sacamuelas only pulled them. An advertisement from May 1799 gave an address «next to the sacamuelas» on Calle de los Preciados, a sign that one of them was well known. The bloodletters, who let blood, also pulled teeth: they learned it for their exam. In the imagined story, the family goes to the bloodletter because he is the closest.
  4. According to the manual the bloodletters studied, to pull a molar the patient sat on the floor; for a lower root, on a high seat. If he did not know which tooth hurt, the bloodletter tapped them one by one with the handle of the gatillo, the most common forceps. Afterwards the gum was pressed with the fingers and the patient rinsed with lukewarm water and vinegar (the treatise of 1799 agrees), and the manual added that he should not go out into the cold air without covering his mouth. All of this is attributed to the manual; that the episode's bloodletter acted this way is imagination.
  5. That is not known: none of the sources consulted gives what pulling a tooth cost in Madrid that year, and the episode says so instead of inventing a figure. It is recorded that the dentists who advertised said they treated the poor for free, and that in advertisements of 1800 and 1801 a small bottle or a paper of powders against toothache cost 4 to 10 reales. There was no anesthesia either: in Madrid, ether was first used for operating in January 1847, 48 years later. For discussion: what is the difference between «we do not know» and «it did not happen»?

Activity: What is known and what is imagined

The episode's family (the grandfather with the toothache, the mother, the father, a journeyman at a tannery on the Ribera de Curtidores, and the daughter) is a declared composite: it is imagined from advertisements in the Diario de Madrid from 1797 to 1801, a trade guide of 1799 and three books of the time, and the narrator flags it with phrases such as «let us imagine that» or «our family». This activity trains students to read that difference. They place each detail of the day in columns: what the sources document about the Madrid of the time, what is imagined for this family and what is told about another place or another year.

  1. Watch the first chapter (minute 0:00) and note how the narrator says that the grandfather and his family are imagined.
  2. Watch «Cloves, plasters and a poultice» (minute 1:33). In a table, put in one column what the books say (cloves, plasters on the temples, the poultice of bread crumb and milk) and in another what the episode imagines (that the mother is the one who tries them, one after another, through the morning; that the father works at the tannery).
  3. Mark what is told about another place or another year: the cigar of bull-horn shavings that farmers around Cartagena smoked, according to a letter of 1800, and what a Madrid dentist recommended in 1807. They are real facts, but one is from another city and the other from eight years later.
  4. Watch «The bloodletter: down on the floor» (minute 10:14). Note what the manual says (the posture, the gatillo, the rinse) and the bloodletter's shop on Calle de la Ruda that was up for transfer in May 1799, and separate it from what is imagined: that this family went there and that the grandfather sat on the floor of that shop.
  5. To debate: if the episode said «the grandfather sat on the floor and had his tooth pulled» with no «let us imagine», what would a viewer believe? What is gained and what is lost by saying «we do not know what they charged him»?

Words

sacamuelas[sah-kah-MWEH-lahs]
A tooth-puller: someone who only pulled teeth, without a dentist's licence, often travelling from square to square.
sangrador[sahn-grah-DOR]
A licensed bloodletter, who also applied leeches and cupping and pulled teeth.
gatillo[gah-TEE-yoh]
Iron forceps for pulling molars; the most common tool.
Protomedicato[proh-toh-meh-dee-KAH-toh]
The royal board that examined and licensed medical practitioners.
santa Polonia[Saint Apollonia: uh-puh-LOH-nee-uh]
Saint Apollonia of Alexandria, invoked against toothache; her feast day is 9 February.
hilas[—]
Lint: threads pulled from linen cloth, used for dressings.
almáciga[—]
Mastic, an aromatic resin chewed or packed into the tooth.
opiata[—]
A paste for cleaning and whitening the teeth; it contains no opium.
cuarto bajo[KWAR-toh BAH-hoh]
A ground-floor flat in a tenement house, often facing the courtyard.
real[reh-AHL, plural reh-AH-lehs]
The everyday unit of money.

To read

The full text of the story, chapter by chapter, is on its page.

For Spanish class

The video has a Spanish audio track: on YouTube, open Settings (⚙) → Audio track → Spanish, and turn on subtitles (CC) if you want them.

Note

The episode speaks of pain, of pulling teeth without anesthesia and, in passing, of bloodletting (if nothing worked, the bloodletter let blood); the extraction is told without detail. One sentence mentions a Goya print in which a woman tries to pull the teeth of a hanged man, which according to a comment of the time were believed to serve for spells. The remedies are told as history and the video warns that none is recommended today: it is worth repeating this in class.

It plays with YouTube Restricted Mode on.

Sources

Share and print

WhatsApp Google Classroom

Free to use in class, no sign-up. For homework, link to the video on YouTube.